Home / Case Studies / Sydney Insurance Defence Firm (anonymised)
Case study

Sydney Insurance Defence Firm Cuts Matter Costs 28%

38 lawyers
Sydney, NSW
Insurance Defence
Workers Comp
Professional Indemnity
The outcome

A 38-lawyer Sydney insurance defence firm uses Quillio across CTP claims under the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 (NSW), workers compensation under the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998 (NSW) and WCA 1987 (NSW), professional indemnity defence, and public liability matters. Per-matter cost to the insurer panel is down around 28%, and the firm kept three panel appointments that were under fee-pressure review.

Run the same pilot — free trial
The challenge

What they were trying to solve

Insurance panel work runs on tight fee scales — insurers expect fixed fees for standard matter types, and margin has been squeezed steadily for a decade. The firm was defending panel review threats on three major books. Associates were doing the volume of brief analysis, particulars of claim review, and expert report triage that the fee scale no longer supported, and partners were subsidising too many matters with unbilled time.

The solution

Why Quillio

Quillio was configured with the MAIA 2017 (NSW), WIMWC Act 1998 (NSW), WCA 1987 (NSW), PIC practice rules, Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW), Legal Profession Uniform Law, and the major insurer panel billing and reporting templates. Associates now process claim briefs through Quillio and produce the standard insurer reports (coverage, liability, quantum, reserving recommendation) in a fraction of the time.

Implementation

Pilot across the CTP and workers comp teams over eight weeks, benchmarked against 40 closed matter files to confirm the output matched the insurer reporting standard. PI and public liability extended in month three. Panel-specific reporting template automation added in month four.

Results

Measurable outcomes

Down 28%
Per-matter cost to insurer

Across CTP, workers comp, and PI on the firm's three largest panel books

4 hours → 50 minutes
Claim brief analysis

Coverage, liability, and initial reserving memo

Same-day
Panel reporting turnaround

Quarterly panel reports produced automatically from matter data

3 at risk → all retained
Panel appointments retained

After the firm demonstrated cost reduction and faster reporting

Preserved
Associate billables maintained

Volume up, rate unchanged — margin restored by cost reduction, not rate increase

"
Panel insurers don't care about our problems — they care about the cost per claim and the quality of the report. Quillio let us show both moving in the right direction in the same quarter. We went from a panel review conversation to a capacity expansion conversation.
Michael D.
Managing Partner · Sydney Insurance Defence Firm (anonymised)
In their day

How it works in practice

CTP claims defence under the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 (NSW), workers compensation under the WIMWC Act 1998 and WCA 1987 (NSW) with Personal Injury Commission practice, professional indemnity defence under the Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW), public liability, insurer panel reporting (coverage, liability, quantum, reserving), and LPUL compliance.

What they avoided

Losing panel appointments that represented a significant share of firm revenue, or cutting associate headcount in response to the fee pressure that started the review.

Questions

Case study FAQs

Does Quillio handle NSW CTP and workers comp?

Yes — the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 (NSW) and MACA 1999 (NSW), WIMWC Act 1998 (NSW), WCA 1987 (NSW), SIRA guidelines, PIC practice directions, and the standard injury assessment matrices.

Can it produce insurer panel reports?

Yes — Quillio is configured with the major insurer panel templates (coverage, liability, quantum, reserving) and produces same-day reports for adjusters.

What about confidentiality on insurer data?

All matter data stays on Australian-hosted infrastructure under the firm's tenancy. Nothing is used for external model training. Insurer-specific data is partitioned and access-controlled per panel.

Does it handle PI and public liability?

Yes — Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW) analysis, Ipp reforms, professional indemnity under the LPUL for legal PI claims, and the standard public liability defences and contributory negligence analysis.

Can it flag coverage issues?

Yes — Quillio reviews insurance policy wordings against claims facts and flags likely coverage disputes, deductibles, exclusions, and reserving recommendations for the adjuster.

Run the same pilot.

Insurance defence firms should trial Quillio on a batch of CTP or workers comp matters — measure per-matter cost and panel reporting quality against current baseline. Start a free trial.

Start your free trial