Defending an AVO application in the NSW Local Court
An AVO is a civil order but has serious consequences — firearms licence, employment, and potential breach offences. A defended AVO hearing runs on the civil balance of probabilities but often involves the same witnesses as related criminal proceedings.
This is an 8-step workflow for defending a NSW Apprehended Violence Order application in the Local Court under the Crimes (Domestic and Personal Violence) Act 2007 (NSW).
Before you start
- Instructions taken about the alleged incidents
- Police fact sheet and any body-worn video reviewed
- Consideration of whether to negotiate an order without admissions
- Advice given about firearms and employment consequences
The workflow
Obtain the application and supporting material
Obtain the application for an AVO, police statements, and any subsidiary evidence from the prosecution. Request disclosure of body-worn video and 000 calls.
Take detailed instructions
Take detailed instructions on each incident particularised in the application, including context, witnesses, and any documentary evidence held by the defendant.
Advise on consent without admissions
Advise the defendant about consent without admissions under s 78. This option avoids a hearing but still creates firearms and employment consequences.
Assess the s 16 elements
Assess whether the protected person has reasonable grounds to fear and actually fears a relevant personal violence offence. Identify weaknesses in the prosecution case.
Consider parallel criminal proceedings
Consider how any parallel criminal charges affect the AVO strategy — cross-examination in the AVO can be used in related criminal proceedings.
Prepare defence witness outlines
Prepare outlines of evidence for the defendant and any defence witnesses, focusing on the reasonableness of any alleged fear and factual disputes.
Subpoena relevant records
Issue subpoenas for police running sheets, text messages, and any relevant third-party records. Attend the subpoena return date.
Run the defended hearing
Run the defended hearing — cross-examine the protected person and officer, lead defence evidence, and make submissions on the absence of the s 16 elements.
What you will have at the end
A defended hearing outcome — the application is dismissed, or an AVO is made on the terms the court determines. The defendant can appeal the decision to the District Court within 28 days.
Common issues
- Not advising the defendant about firearms and security licence consequences
- Conceding interim orders without considering the strategic impact
- Missing the interaction with family law parenting orders under s 68R
- Poor preparation of the defendant for cross-examination
- Failing to tender text message chronologies where helpful
Run this workflow on a real matter
Quillio drafts witness outlines, cross-examination plans, and written submissions on the s 16 elements. See /practice-areas/criminal-lawyers or start a free trial.
This workflow is a general guide for NSW AVOs. Other jurisdictions have different names and procedures for equivalent orders.
Try this workflow with Quillio.
Quillio can run this workflow on a real matter, with citations to current AU authority on every step. The free trial requires no credit card.
Start your free trial