Section 10 dismissal / conditional release application (NSW)
A s 10 result means no conviction is recorded. The court weighs the triviality of the offence, the offender's character and antecedents, and extenuating circumstances before deciding whether recording a conviction is appropriate.
This is an 8-step workflow for preparing a sentencing submission seeking a s 10(1)(a) dismissal, a s 10(1)(b) conditional release order without conviction, or a s 10A non-conviction order in the NSW Local Court.
Before you start
- Client pleading guilty (or already convicted) to a summary or Table offence
- Facts sheet and criminal history
- Instructions on the client's personal circumstances, employment, and health
- Any mitigation documents including counselling reports or letters of apology
The workflow
Assess s 10 suitability
Apply the s 10(3) factors — trivial nature of the offence, offender's character, extenuating circumstances — to assess realistic prospects. Check whether statutory bars apply (e.g. certain driving offences have 5-year rules).
Negotiate the facts
Where possible, negotiate the police facts to remove aggravating features that would count against a s 10 outcome. File amended facts with the prosecutor in advance of sentence.
Gather character references
Obtain 3-6 current character references addressed to the presiding magistrate. References should acknowledge the offence, be dated, and come from referees with standing.
Obtain rehabilitation evidence
Gather evidence of steps taken since the offence — traffic offender programs, MERIT, addiction counselling, psychology reports, or community service undertaken voluntarily.
Draft written sentencing submissions
Prepare a concise submissions document structured around s 10(3). Open with the relief sought, address each factor, and close with proposed conditions for a CRO.
Prepare the proposed CRO conditions
If seeking a s 10(1)(b) CRO, draft realistic conditions — good behaviour, supervision, specific prohibitions — that the magistrate can accept without modification.
Appear at sentence
At sentence, tender the materials in a logical bundle, make focused oral submissions, and address the magistrate's concerns directly. Avoid re-litigating guilt.
Obtain the orders and advise the client
After sentence, obtain a copy of the orders and explain their effect — particularly that a CRO can be breached and re-sentenced. Advise on spent convictions if a conviction was recorded.
What you will have at the end
A sentencing outcome without conviction (s 10 dismissal, s 10(1)(b) CRO, or s 10A) — or at minimum, a strong mitigation record for the ultimate sentence imposed.
Common issues
- Not checking for statutory bars on non-conviction outcomes (drink driving 5-year rule under the Road Transport Act)
- Weak or generic character references that undermine the application
- Trying to litigate the facts at sentence rather than negotiating them in advance
- Overstating rehabilitation without supporting documentation
- Failing to propose workable CRO conditions
Run this workflow on a real matter
Quillio drafts NSW sentencing submissions aligned to s 10(3) and produces character reference templates calibrated to the presiding magistrate's sentencing patterns. See /practice-areas/criminal-lawyers.
This workflow is a general guide. S 10 outcomes are discretionary — statutory bars, prior convictions, and the objective seriousness of the offence all bear on the outcome.
Try this workflow with Quillio.
Quillio can run this workflow on a real matter, with citations to current AU authority on every step. The free trial requires no credit card.
Start your free trial