Handling an off-the-plan purchase dispute
Off-the-plan disputes commonly arise from construction delay, material changes, or sunset clause termination. The NSW regime gives purchasers enhanced rights, and vendors must apply to the Supreme Court before relying on sunset termination.
This is an 8-step workflow for handling an off-the-plan purchase dispute in NSW, including purchaser rescission rights, vendor termination, and sunset clause issues under the Conveyancing Act 1919 (NSW).
Before you start
- Copy of the contract and disclosure statement obtained
- Nature of the dispute clearly identified
- Strata plan registration status confirmed
- Deposit bond or trust arrangements understood
The workflow
Review contract and disclosure statement
Review the contract of sale and disclosure statement lodged under the Conveyancing (Sale of Land) Regulation 2022. Identify the sunset date, key terms, and any notified changes.
Identify the dispute category
Identify whether the dispute involves a material change, construction delay, defective work, or sunset clause — each triggers different statutory rights.
Check material particulars
Check whether there has been a change to a material particular disclosed to the purchaser. Material changes may entitle the purchaser to rescind and recover the deposit.
Assess sunset clause position
Assess the sunset clause position. A vendor who wants to terminate under the sunset clause must apply to the Supreme Court and demonstrate it is just and equitable.
Consider quality-of-construction issues
Consider whether the completed lot materially differs from the approved plans and specifications and whether the building defects regime under the DBP Act is engaged.
Draft correspondence
Draft formal correspondence particularising the dispute, the relief sought, and any time limits for response. Serve in accordance with the contract notice provisions.
Negotiate or escalate
Negotiate with the other party, considering price adjustment, scope variation, or deed of variation. Escalate to mediation or Supreme Court proceedings if required.
Finalise resolution or proceedings
Finalise the resolution with a deed of settlement or, if proceedings are commenced, prepare and file the relevant originating process in the Supreme Court.
What you will have at the end
A resolved off-the-plan dispute — either by agreement, rescission and deposit recovery, or Supreme Court determination of sunset termination or specific performance.
Common issues
- Missing the s 66ZL material particular notification requirements
- Vendors attempting to terminate under the sunset clause without Supreme Court leave
- Failing to coordinate with DBP Act defect claims
- Not preserving rights through correct contractual notices
- Overlooking deposit protection under the trust or deposit bond
Run this workflow on a real matter
Quillio drafts rescission notices and Supreme Court sunset clause applications, mapping the contract against the Conveyancing Act provisions. See /practice-areas/property-lawyers or start a free trial.
This workflow is a general guide for NSW off-the-plan disputes. Other jurisdictions have different statutory regimes for off-the-plan contracts.
Try this workflow with Quillio.
Quillio can run this workflow on a real matter, with citations to current AU authority on every step. The free trial requires no credit card.
Start your free trial